Cosmic Rays: The Most Energetic Particles in the Universe and Where They Come From

In October 1991, a particle detector in Utah registered a cosmic ray with an energy of 3 × 10^20 electron volts — more energy in a single subatomic particle than a baseball pitched at 50 miles per hour, focused into a proton smaller than a nucleus. The event was nicknamed the "Oh-My-God particle" because its energy was so far beyond anything known that no conventional astrophysical source seemed capable of producing it. Cosmic rays in this ultra-high-energy range should not even be able to travel across the universe — they should be degraded to lower energies by collisions with photons in the cosmic microwave background, a process called the GZK limit. The Oh-My-God particle violated the GZK limit. Something in the local universe — within roughly 50 megaparsecs — was accelerating particles to impossible energies. The source has still not been definitively identified.

What happened

Cosmic rays were discovered in 1912 by Victor Hess, who ascended in a balloon to find that ionizing radiation increased with altitude rather than decreasing — proof that it came from above rather than from the Earth's natural radioactivity. By the mid-20th century, cosmic rays were known to be mostly protons (about 90%), with helium nuclei, heavier ions, electrons, and a small fraction of antiparticles making up the rest.

Most cosmic rays have energies in the range of a billion to a trillion electron volts — similar to the energies produced by supernova shock waves accelerating particles through repeated magnetic scattering, a mechanism called Fermi acceleration. There is strong evidence that supernovae in the Milky Way are the dominant source of cosmic rays below about 10^15 eV. Above that energy — the "knee" of the cosmic ray spectrum — the composition and source become less certain.

At ultra-high energies (above 10^18 eV, the "ankle"), cosmic rays are thought to be extragalactic — they cannot be confined by the Milky Way's magnetic field at those energies and must originate from sources beyond our galaxy. The Pierre Auger Observatory in Argentina, the largest cosmic ray detector ever built (covering 3,000 km² of pampas with 1,600 water-Cherenkov detectors and 27 fluorescence telescopes), has detected thousands of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays and shown that they have a mild anisotropy — a slight excess from a broad region of sky roughly in the direction of the Virgo Cluster and the nearby distribution of matter. This suggests but does not prove that active galactic nuclei are the dominant sources.

The best candidates for ultra-high-energy cosmic ray acceleration are: active galactic nuclei (AGN), whose relativistic jets can in principle accelerate particles to the required energies; gamma-ray bursts; and magnetars (highly magnetized neutron stars). A 2017 paper from Auger reported a correlation between the arrival directions of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays and starburst galaxies, with the nearby starburst galaxy Centaurus A (also an AGN) as the leading individual source candidate.

Why it matters

Cosmic ray physics is where particle physics and astrophysics intersect most dramatically. The particles at the top of the cosmic ray spectrum carry energies 10^8 times higher than the LHC — they are nature's way of doing experiments that no human accelerator can replicate. When these particles hit Earth's atmosphere, they produce extensive air showers — cascades of hundreds of billions of secondary particles that shower down over many square kilometers. Measuring these showers with ground detectors and fluorescence telescopes is how Auger detects the primary cosmic rays.

The puzzle of their origin is not just academic. The acceleration mechanism responsible for ultra-high-energy cosmic rays is almost certainly associated with the most extreme environments in the universe — black hole jets, neutron star mergers, gamma-ray bursts. Understanding cosmic ray acceleration is therefore a window into the physics of these environments and a constraint on the electromagnetic and gravitational processes that drive them.

Cosmic rays also produce muons that penetrate deep underground — the primary background noise in dark matter detectors and neutrino observatories. Understanding cosmic ray physics is therefore necessary for suppressing this background in the most sensitive detectors of other rare phenomena.

How to think about it

Cosmic rays are in some ways the most extreme form of astronomy: rather than passively collecting photons, we are detecting individual subatomic particles that have traveled across the universe and arrived at our atmosphere with energy equivalent to macroscopic objects. The Oh-My-God particle carried the kinetic energy of a baseball — compressed into a single proton.

The question of what accelerates particles to such energies is one of the deepest in astrophysics. The answer must involve electromagnetic fields of extraordinary strength over vast distances — the conditions that exist only in the immediate environments of the most massive black holes, the densest neutron star fields, or the shockwaves of the most powerful explosions. Finding the Oh-My-God particle's source would solve one of those mysteries.

The connection to particle physics is equally profound. The Oh-My-God particle and its near-equal-energy companions probe quantum chromodynamics and other standard model physics at energy scales that are simply inaccessible any other way. The LHC produces center-of-mass energies of 14 TeV. An ultra-high-energy cosmic ray hitting a stationary nucleus has a center-of-mass energy in excess of 100 TeV — an order of magnitude higher. Nature is doing particle physics experiments that we cannot replicate.

FAQ